2750 Fenwick Avenue

City living. 2750 Fenwick Avenue.

City living ca. 1920. My grandmother on the right with unidentified woman and children at 2750 Fenwick Avenue, Baltimore.

What’s exciting about most of these photos is the possibility, maybe even the likelihood, that no one alive now has ever seen them before. I discovered them when I opened two tiny manila envelopes – smaller than seed packets – that had been sealed long ago and upon which someone had written “Fenwick Ave.” They were in a large box of photos, letters and ephemera relating to various aunts and uncles and cousins, that had come from my Aunt Miriam, though the envelopes appeared to have been sealed for so long that I can imagine she never opened them. The box contained similar envelopes marked “Arizona” and “Genoa”. I knew what the latter would be: photos taken by or of my grandfather during his long tour of the American West as a school teacher. But I had never heard of Fenwick Avenue. I guessed it was in Baltimore somewhere, but I didn’t know what its significance was. Perusal of the tiny, curled, mostly undated photographic prints inside immediately told that this was a place that my grandparents James and Jennie Fleagle lived in before they lived at the Walstan Avenue house in Reisterstown.

I searched out James Fleagle in a Baltimore City census from 1920. Sure as shootin’, when I found James’ household – himself, his wife, his first son, James Lincoln, and his mother-in-law Margaret (Foster) Coffin – the name Fenwick was written along the edge, where the census workers wrote down the street name. The then-little family was listed as residing at number 2750 (later inspection of several of these photos with a magnifying glass revealed this number appended to both the front wall and the back porch). I then looked that location up on maps and aerial photographs. The house was still there in 1971 but disappeared sometime between then and 2002. The weedy lot is empty now.

The empty lot where stood the block of four townhouses that included 2750. Bing Maps captured this image after 2014.

The empty lot where stood the block of four townhouses that included 2750. Bing Maps captured this image after 2014.

I realized pretty quickly that the photo I’d posted earlier of my grandfather with his first four children and his mother-in-law must have been shot in the back yard of this home on Fenwick. When I’d posted it I had assumed it was taken at Walstan, but I completely missed the fact that the wall behind them is constructed of brick, whereas Walstan was (and is still) a wood-frame house.

The back yard at the Fenwick house. It is difficult to see but there is a human subject; my guess is James L. Fleagle (James Jr.)

The back yard at the Fenwick house. It is difficult to see but there is a human subject; I assume it is James L. Fleagle (James Jr.)

The envelope turned out to be full of gilded moments in the lives of the Fleagle children captured on film, mostly in the side and back yards of 2750 and mostly out of focus. But since the subject of this post is the Fenwick house itself, I’ve chosen out a few images that show rather more of it than less, or some detail, or the yard or neighboring houses. Many of the backyard shots were composed around the same shrub as the one I posted before, at various stages of its growth over the years. (It seems many families have a shrub they run out to on auspicious occasions – we had a rhododendron.)

The neighborhood has remained structurally unchanged for the most part, although surrounding houses have periodically been razed, and in July of this year (2016), six of the next seven houses to the north – just around the street bend – caught fire and burned. The neighborhood’s trajectory has been a steady dilapidation, it seems. But the house nextdoor to the south remains, whose wall and windows appear as the backdrop in so many of the photographs.

A baby (possibly Miriam) plays in front of the Fenwick house. Note the houses in the background around the bend to the north. They are visible in the bottom photograph below. They burned in 2016.

A baby (my guess is Miriam) plays in front of the Fenwick house. Note the houses in the background over the baby’s shoulder. They are visible in the last photograph in this post. They burned in 2016.

My grandfather James Fleagle with two children. I think they might be Jimmy and Miriam.

James Ezra Fleagle, and probably firstborn Jim and infant Miriam, on the front porch of 2750 Fenwick. I would put the date somewhere in the first half of 1921.

I’m pretty sure that’s Carlton Jones on the left in the photo below, and I think his wife Ruth (Fleagle) Jones, my grandfather’s sister, is on the right (compare their faces with those labelled here) looking down at two children who are unfamiliar to me. My guess is that Carlton is holding his son Jimmy Jones. Maggie (Foster) Coffin is probably holding my Uncle Ben in the middle. Jennie (Coffin) Fleagle, my grandmother, is between her mother and sister-in-law, in the dark dress. Miriam, with hands together, has her head turned toward her older brother Jim. The house behind them is the one to the south, still standing today. This photo is dated Apr 24, but that can’t be right — in that case Ben would be only a few days old, or none, since he was born that month. Another photo dated “apr 24” and taken surely on the same occasion – the three Fleagle children are dressed just as they are here, including young Jim’s hat and Miriam’s dress – has ’24’ crossed out and ’25’ penciled in. It makes more sense that this is April 1925, but Vivian, not visible here, was born in May of that year, just a month later, so why doesn’t Jennie look more pregnant?

These visitors look like Carlton and Ruth (Fleagle) Jones.

The adults bookending this pose look to me like Carlton and Ruth (Fleagle) Jones. And is that a lilac behind them?

Jimmy holding Viv, Ben on the tricycle, Miriam front right.

Jimmy holding Viv, Ben on the tricycle, Miriam front right. This must be around 1926, the last year the family lived on Fenwick Avenue.

My father never mentioned this place, and that was because he never knew it. With my Uncle Dick, my dad Willard was one of the two youngest children in his family, born after the move to Reisterstown (albeit in Dick’s case just two weeks after) so the Walstan house was the only home he knew as a child. So I asked my Aunt Miriam if she remembered Fenwick Avenue. Jim and Ben are gone, and Vivian would have been too young to have formed any memory of it.

“Yes, I remember my old neighborhood very well. It was a happy time for me…” Miriam wrote back. “It was the first house that my parents owned, and it was the only house, I think, that had property accessible to the street – as we had a side yard…

View of Fenwick Avenue facing east, sometime before 2014. The remaining two (interior) townhomes in the block of four have since been razed.

View of Fenwick Avenue facing east, sometime before 2014. Occupying the lot outlined in yellow, number 2750 was one of the two end houses in the block of four.

“The little store across from our house was Sheetinhelm’s Store which probably sold groceries – but to us children, it was the candy store. The candy was displayed near the front door, and if I remember correctly, didn’t have too many customers. We would go over with our pennies held in our “hot, little hands” and choose what we wanted. Often it would take a long time to choose, but Mr. Sheetinhelm was very patient. Sometimes we would drop our penny down the drain in front of his store. Would you believe he would go out, lift up the grate and retrieve our penny for us? Gone are the days!!!

2750 was in the left-most gap here, where the solid brick wall is visible. In 2009, both 2750 and the other

Number 2750 was in the left-most gap here, where the solid brick wall is visible. In 2009, both 2750 and the other “exterior” house are gone but the two middle or “interior” houses are still standing. These two also disappeared by 2014.

“We went to church and Sunday School near by – I think it was Homewood Methodist Church. I think Robin Taylor was baptized there years later. We went to school (I was in kindergarten) at Montebello School, also near. I don’t know how we got there. Probably walked. Fenwick Ave. ran between Clifton Park at one end (Harford Road) and 28th St. at the other end. City College (a high school) was on 33rd Street, and my father who taught French & German there, walked to his school…

REFERENCE ONLY. Baltimore City Life Museum Collection 8x10 inch Glass Negatives Box 02

Looking northwest up Fenwick Avenue from Harford Road, December 8, 1930. The houses at the far end of the street are the same houses in the photo of the baby above. They burned in July 2016. Image courtesy of the Maryland Historical Society, (CC2642); used by permission.

“One day I noticed Mother had picked the lilacs and put them in a vase on the dining room table. So I took the flowers and went down to the other end of our block, and sold them to a nice lady there. When Mother found out, she was mortified! She went out and picked some fresh lilacs and took them down to the lady. The lady laughed and said, ‘I knew they weren’t fresh, but the little girl was so cute, I just went along with it.’ I think her name was Mrs. Bowman.” – mdf

Image archive IDs:
First image: 20161115-001_fenwick_front
Second image (not counting modern street view): 20161115-004_fenwick_backyard_jim
Third image: 20161115-008_fenwick_front_baby
Fourth image: 20161115-012_fenwick_james_two_children
Fifth image: 20161115-013_fenwick_jones_visit
Sixth image: 20161115-003_fenwick_jimmimbenviv

About the physical photographs:
All of the photographs are approx. 2″ x 3″
Written on back of 20161115-013_fenwick_jones_visit
“apr 24”
(probably incorrect)


4 thoughts on “2750 Fenwick Avenue

    • Thanks for reading, Cousin! I love combining the mission here, which is to preserve and share family photos and history, with one of my other fascinations, which is investigating the way neighborhoods change over time, and how certain structures and other elements remain steadfast through (and despite) the changes.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.